Lily D. (puppet performer) / Loomis
The Golem / Officer Griggs
Lily D. (puppet performer) / Alien (puppet)
Margery Wright / Evelyn Nester / Molly
Lily Carbo / Becky
Will Johnston / Nathan
Ned / Brandon Carbo
Jake Skinner / Dr. Emil Mangle
Old Gresilda / Mrs. Hollinger
Young Nadia / Adriana
Pumpkinhead #3 / Pumpkinhead 3
Dr. Wright / Sean
Technician / Severe Student
Sara / Alice
Gresilda / Anna
Doll Maker
Marla / Margaret
Lisa / Taylor Turner
Stranger / Ranger Jackson
Anna / Flynn
Mary (voice) / Priscilla
Deputy Knotts / Doctor
Cristen / Emma Williams
Josh / Henry 'Halftime' harrd
