Headless Horseman

Liam

Ava

Kolchak Jefferson Stillwall

Tiffany

Candy (as Elizabeth Prestel)

Nash

Headless / Calvin Montgomery

Doc

Pa Rusk / Sgt. Mosby Rusk

Lizzie

Seth

Johnny Rusk

Sheriff Steve Buck

Sheriff Otis

Davis

Johnny's Gang Member

Wormwood Townfolk